Traders don’t like it when their profession is compared to gambling (and vice versa) because they believe that in trading skills determine if you come out ahead, whereas gambling is seen as a pointless endeavor where skills do not exist and only the desperate people are hoping to hit the jackpot.
However, in today’s world, the stock market has become a topic that you can read about in the news daily or watch 24/7 TV coverage of what is happening in the markets around the world. The way the stock market and trading is displayed and talked about has shifted significantly from sophisticated investing to sensation driven entertainment.
The implications of such a presentation and the impacts on the mindset and on the trading approach can be significant, without people even knowing how and why their trading decisions are being manipulated and impacted. The following article has been inspired by a chapter from the book “The indomitable investor : why a few succeed in the stock market when everyone else fails” where the parallels between the world of casinos and the stock market are compared.
Casino vs. Stock Market
When people go to the casino, they often have a very detailed game-plan about how disciplined they are going to play, what their risk limit is, how much they are willing to lose at most and plans about leaving with more than what they came with. However, the casino managers are aware of the ‘preparation’ of the average gambler and they found ways to trick them into abandoning their good intentions.
- Free alcoholic drinks to seduce people to take more risk than what they had planned
- Women and other attractions to create arousal and to stop people from thinking too much about risk and potential losses
- Bright and flashy lights and sounds to create a casual atmosphere with lots of excitement
- Everything in a Casino is designed to make you want to spend your money, often created by professionals with a psychological background, including odors, sounds, patterns of the carpets, etc.
- Casino chips are used to make you forget you are actually playing with real money
The Stock Market
Although trading and investing is a very hard thing to do successfully, the way the media presents investing in the stock market is comparable to a large scale casino where the only goal is to create attention, excitement and awaken the hopes of people who are looking for a fast buck. The following attributes of the mainstream media and trading websites often create a wrong impression of trading and can be the cause of a negative trading performance:
- TV channels and newspapers use attention grabbing headlines and slogans to attract people
- Pictures and photos of young , rich men are used to awaken hopes and dreams of a certain clientele
- The hosts of investing shows have often little to do with sophisticated investors, but are very emotional to draw a lot of attention
- If there are extreme rallies you can read and hear about it everywhere and you can witness that even ‘the average Joe’ now suddenly sees himself as an investor
Research on investor behavior and media coverage
The fact that financial media and the media coverage is impacting investor behavior is widely researched and 3 findings stand out which highlight the impacts of financial media:
1) Attention-grabbing events lead active individual investors to be net buyers of stocks.
2) Individual investors are more likely to trade an S&P 500 index stock after an earnings announcement if that announcement was covered in the investor’s local newspaper.
3) Investors who have never previously owned a stock are more likely to buy when stocks reach upper price limits such as all-time highs.
You can read more about research findings and find the respective references in our other article.
These three findings show that the media and attention has a big influence on how the average investor makes his decisions. Furthermore, even if you think that you make your decisions completely independent, being exposed to very emotional and convincing reports or announcements can lead to trading decisions that deviate from your original plan. The next points will show how a trader can protect himself from such negative influences.
Implications for your own trading and tips to counteract the outside influence
#1 “Think slow to think at all”
Before you make a decision, think about what caused to you think in a certain way. Before entering a trade, ask yourself whether the trade idea is based on sound principles and your trading rules,or did get you the idea from an outside source? To be profitable over the long-term, a trader has to make his decisions self-determined and based on his own research.
“Give a man a stock tip, and you feed him for a day; show him how to trade, and you feed him for a lifetime.” – Modern_Rock
#2 Who do you engage with during trading?
It is OK to interact with other traders and talk about experiences or personal views. But during trading sessions, traders should be somewhat isolated. Being active in forums, trading chat rooms or listening to financial news can influence your own decision making process. Amateur traders often look for outside confirmation when a trade goes against them and then they ask other traders, often with completely different trading methodologies, why a trade is still good.
“When a trade goes wrong if you’re looking for confirmation bias instead of hitting stops, you don’t have the mental strength to be a trader.” – Assad Tannous
#3 Check your surroundings
As we have seen above, the atmosphere in casinos can have big impacts on how we perceive risk and act in situations. Therefore, be aware of the music you play while trading and avoid anything that is too arousing – some traders report that they listen to classical music during trading sessions to keep their level of arousal low. Do you really need to have CNBC running at all times? To bypass periods where nothing happens, do you watch funny YouTube videos or engage in any other activity that could have an impact on your mood?
This point might sound over the top, but everything around us, and the activities we engage in directly impact how we perceive risk and make our decisions, even though we might not be aware of it at first glance.
#4 The colors on your chart
As we have seen, even the color and pattern of the carpet in a casino has the purpose to make people loosen up, feel comfortable and lull them into plying more.
The colors we use in our trading platforms impact how we perceive the current price development. All our lives we are primed to respond to the two most commonly used signal colors red and green. Whenever we see green, it means go and everything is good, whereas red signals an immediate stop or danger.
Are traders more likely to engage in impulsive trading decisions when they are currently faced with a big green or red candle? Very likely. Are you more likely to close a buy trade when the current candle is red? Possibly. Even if the impact is minor, a trader should grab every possibility to put the odds a little more in your favor should be embraced.
credit: the source of the images is Pixabay.com